(Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science. 2000;41:2352-2356.)
© 2000
by The Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology, Inc.
Localization of Tubby-like Protein 1 in Developing and Adult Human Retinas
Ann H. Milam1,
Anita E. Hendrickson2,3,
Ming Xiao2,
Julie E. Smith1,
Daniel E. Possin3,
Sinoj K. John1 and
Patsy M. Nishina4
1 From the Scheie Eye Institute, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia; the Departments of
2 Biological Structure and
3 Ophthalmology, University of Washington, Seattle; and
4 The Jackson Laboratory, Bar Harbor, Maine.
 |
Abstract
|
|---|
PURPOSE. To localize tubby-like protein 1 (TULP1) in developing and adult human retinas.
METHODS. TULP1 was localized by immunofluorescence microscopy in human retinas,
aged 8.4 fetal weeks to adult. TULP1-positive cells were identified by
double labeling with antibodies specific for cones, rods, and astrocytes.
RESULTS. In adult retinas, anti-TULP1 labels cone and rod inner segments,
somata, and synapses; outer segments are TULP1-negative. A few inner
nuclear and ganglion cells are weakly TULP1- positive. In fetal
retinas, cells at the outer retinal border are TULP1-positive at 8.4
weeks. At 11 weeks, the differentiating central cones are strongly
TULP1-reactive and some are positive for blue cone opsin. At 15.4
weeks, all central cones are strongly positive for TULP1 and many are
reactive for red/green cone opsin. At 17.4 weeks, central rods are
weakly TULP-reactive. In peripheral retina at 15.4 weeks to 1 month
after birth, displaced cones in the nerve fiber layer are positive for
TULP1, recoverin, and blue cone opsin. Some ganglion cells are weakly
reactive for TULP1 at 11 weeks and later, but astrocytes and the optic
nerve are TULP1-negative at all ages examined.
CONCLUSIONS. The finding of TULP1 labeling of cones before they are reactive for
blue or red/green cone opsin suggests an important role for TULP1 in
development. TULP1 expression in both developing and mature cones and
rods is consistent with a primary photoreceptor defect in retinitis
pigmentosa (RP) caused by TULP1 mutations. Weak
TULP1-immunolabeling of some inner retinal neurons in developing and
adult retinas suggests that optic disc changes in patients with RP who
have TULP1 mutations may be primary as well as secondary to
photoreceptor degeneration.
 |
Introduction
|
|---|
In tubby mice, also known as retinal degeneration 5
(rd5), a recessive mutation in the tub gene
causes progressive retinal and cochlear degeneration and adult-onset
obesity with insulin resistance.1
2
The mutation in the
tub gene that leads to these phenotypic alterations is a
G
T transversion that abolishes a donor splice site, leading to
replacement of the carboxyl-terminal 44 amino acids with a 20amino
acid sequence not found in the wild-type protein.3
Tub is a member of a small neuronally expressed gene
family that includes human TUB (homologous to mouse
tub), tubby-like protein 1 (TULP1),
TULP2, and TULP3. The tubby proteins have a
highly conserved carboxyl terminal region but divergent amino
terminals, and related proteins are found in lower animals and plants.
The TUB gene is expressed in multiple human tissues
including retina, whereas the TULP1 gene product is found
mainly in retina. TULP2 is expressed primarily in
testis,4
and TULP3 is found in multiple
tissues, including the retina.5
6
Recent evidence suggests that TULP1 is a transcription factor involved
in control of downstream genes in retinal photoreceptors.7
Autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa (RP) develops in patients
homozygous for mutations in the TULP1
gene.8
9
10
11
A recent report of a large family in the
Dominican Republic described the phenotype of patients homozygous for a
splice site mutation (IVS14 + 1, G
A) in the conserved carboxyl
region of TULP1 gene.11
In the first decade of
life, the affected persons have nystagmus, absent rod function, and
severely impaired cone function throughout the retina. The early vision
loss is suggested to result from photoreceptor maldevelopment,
dysfunction, or degeneration.11
The Dominican Republic family members with RP also show early optic
disc abnormalities suggestive of degenerative changes in the ganglion
cells and/or the optic nerve. One study of mouse retina found
tub expression restricted to ganglion cells during
embryogenesis and mainly in photoreceptors in postnatal and adult
animals.12
A more recent study found tub
expressed in both ganglion cells and photoreceptors in adult mouse
retina.6
The clinical findings, together with the
tub expression pattern in retina, raises the question of
whether TULP1 is expressed not only in photoreceptors but
also in ganglion cells and the optic nerve in developing human
retinas.11
Recent studies6
13
demonstrate
TULP1-immunolabeling of mouse photoreceptors. However, cones are a
minor population in mouse retina, and we wanted to know whether human
cones also express this protein. To resolve these questions and provide
needed information on the pathophysiology of retinal degeneration
caused by TULP1 mutations, we used immunocytochemistry to
localize the TULP1 protein in developing and adult human retinas.
 |
Methods
|
|---|
Tissue Preparation
Adult human eyes were obtained through the donor programs of the
Foundation Fighting Blindness (Hunt Valley, MD) and the University of
Washington Lions Eye Bank (Seattle). Fetal human eyes were obtained
from the University of Washington Human Embryology Laboratory. The
research followed the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki, and
informed consent was obtained from all donors. The research was
approved by the institutional human subjects review boards of the
University of Washington and the University of Pennsylvania. Eight
normal adult retinas were evaluated, all fixed at 6 hours or less after
death, along with retinas fixed within 1 hour after death at fetal ages
8.4, 9, 11, 14, 15.4, 17.4, 18, 19, and 21.5 weeks and postnatal ages 3
days and 1 month. The globes were fixed for several weeks to months in
4% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 7.3), and stored
thereafter in 2% paraformaldehyde in the same buffer.
Immunocytochemistry
Retinal samples were cryosectioned at 12 µm and processed for
immunofluorescence according to published techniques.14
The secondary antibodies (goat anti-rabbit or anti-mouse IgG) were
labeled with fluorescein isothiocyanate (green), Cy-2 (green), or Cy-3
(red; Jackson ImmunoResearch, West Grove, PA). Nuclei were stained with
DAPI (1 µg/ml; Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR). Control sections were
treated in the same way with omission of primary antibody.
The anti-TULP1 (TULP1-N) was a rat polyclonal antibody (pAb) against
the amino-terminal half of human TULP1,6
used at a
dilution of 1:750 to 1:1000. Cell-specific antibodies prepared in
rabbits or mice were used for double labeling to analyze the various
retinal cell types labeled with anti-TULP1. Rods were identified with
anti-rhodopsin, a mouse monoclonal antibody (mAb; 4D2; 1:40; from
Robert Molday, University of British Columbia, Vancouver,
Canada). Cones were marked with rabbit pAb anti-blue cone opsin (JH455;
1:50001:10,000) and anti-red/green cone opsin (JH492;
1:50001:10,000; from Jeremy Nathans, Johns Hopkins University,
Baltimore, MD). Cones were also labeled with rabbit pAb anti-red/green
cone opsin (1:200; from John Saari, University of Washington, Seattle).
The rods, cones, and flat midget bipolar cells were identified with
rabbit pAb anti-recoverin (1:1000; from Alexander Dizhoor, Wayne State
University, Detroit, MI). Astrocytes were labeled with pAb anti-glial
fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP; 1:500; Dako, Carpinteria, CA).
Immunolabeled retinal sections were photographed with an
epifluorescence microscope (DMR; Leica, Deerfield, IL) using Elite
Chrome film (ASA 400; Eastman Kodak, Rochester, NY). Images were
digitized with a flatbed scanner (HiRes; Saphir, Heidelberg, Germany)
with Elite 5.1 software (LinoColor, Heidelberg, Germany) and imported
into a graphics program (Photoshop 5.0; Adobe, San Jose, CA) from which
dye-sublimation prints were generated.
 |
Results
|
|---|
Adult Human Retinas
Strong TULP1-immunolabeling was present in rod inner
segments, somata, and synapses (Fig. 1A
). TULP1-reactivity was present but somewhat less intense in the cone
inner segments, whereas cone somata and synapses were heavily labeled
(Fig. 1A)
. No TULP1-labeling was found in rod or cone outer segments
(Fig. 1A) . Double labeling with anti-TULP1 and anti-recoverin
demonstrated absence of TULP1-reactivity in the photoreceptor outer
segments but colocalization of both proteins in the cone and rod inner
segments, somata, and synapses (Figs. 1B
1C)
. A few cells in the inner
nuclear and ganglion cell layers were weakly TULP1-positive (Figs. 1A
1D) . Control sections treated with only Cy3-labeled secondary showed
autofluorescence of lipofuscin in the retinal pigment epithelium (Fig. 1E)
.

View larger version (70K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 1. Adult human retina, age 56 years. (A) Immunolabeling with
anti-TULP1 (red), with DAPI staining (blue) of
nuclei. Note labeled photoreceptor (p) inner segments, somata, and
synapses and weaker labeling of a few cells in the inner nuclear (n)
and ganglion (g) cell layers. (B) Anti-recoverin
(green) labeling, with DAPI-stained nuclei. Note intense
labeling of photoreceptor outer and inner segments, somata, and
synapses and weaker labeling of a few inner nuclear layer cells.
(C) Anti-TULP1 (red) and anti-recoverin
(green) labeling, with DAPI-stained nuclei. Note outer
segment (os) labeling (yellow-green) with anti-recoverin
only and colocalization (gold) of TULP1 and recoverin in the
photoreceptor (p) inner segments, somata, and synapses. (D)
Higher magnification of TULP1-localization. Note TULP1-positive
photoreceptor inner segments (i), somata, and synapses, and a few
TULP1-positive cells in the inner nuclear layer (n). (E)
Control section treated with no primary antibody, with DAPI-stained
nuclei. Note intense autofluorescence of the retinal pigment epithelium
(r). (F) Section of 11 wk fetal retina labeled with
anti-TULP1 with DAPI-stained nuclei. The neuroblast cell nuclei are
stained blue with DAPI. Note intense TULP1-labeling of cells
(*) lying outermost in the retina. Ganglion cells (g) are also
TULP1-positive. Magnification, (A, B, and
C) x102; (D, E, and F)
x193.
|
|
Fetal Human Retinas
Because of the steep developmental gradients in early fetal
retinas,15
sections were studied that were cut along the
horizontal meridian in or near the fovea. All retinal neurons showed a
central to peripheral gradient of maturation, and the fetal retinas
showed a central to peripheral appearance of TULP1-immunolabeling. At
the earliest ages examined, 8.4 and 11 fetal weeks, TULP1-labeling was
found in the outermost cells of the central retina lying opposite the
retinal pigment epithelium (RPE; Fig. 1F
). The remainder of the
neuroblasts, stained intensely blue with DAPI, were weakly
TULP1-positive (Fig. 1F)
.
By 21.5 weeks, the neuroblast layer in the periphery was much thicker
and TULP1-positive throughout (Fig. 2A
). Double labeling with anti-TULP1 and anti-recoverin revealed that the
cells reactive for recoverin (presumed photoreceptors) were restricted
to the outer half of the neuroblast layer (Fig. 2B)
, whereas
TULP1-labeling was also found in undifferentiated progenitor cells in
the inner neuroblast layer (Fig. 2C)
. A thinner layer of cells at the
outermost margin of the retina, just opposite the RPE, was intensely
reactive for both TULP1 and recoverin (Fig. 2C)
.

View larger version (91K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 2. Fetal human retina, age 21.5 weeks. (A) Section labeled with
anti-TULP1, with DAPI-stained nuclei. The neuroblast (n) layer is
TULP1-positive, especially the outermost cells (*). (B)
Same section as in (A) labeled with anti-recoverin, with
DAPI-stained nuclei. Cells in the outer half of the neuroblast layer
are recoverin-positive (p, presumed photoreceptors), especially the
outermost cells (*). (C) Double exposure of section in
(A) and (B) illustrating colocalization
(gold) of TULP1 and recoverin in the layer of developing
photoreceptors (p), especially the outermost cells (*).
(D) TULP1-immunolabeling of differentiating cones
(arrow) in peripheral retina. (E) TULP1-labeling
of differentiating cones in more central retina, with DAPI-stained
nuclei. All differentiating photoreceptors are TULP1-positive, but the
cones (arrows) are more intensely labeled than the
differentiating rods (r) lying more vitread. Ganglion cells (g) are
weakly TULP1-positive, and one cell (arrowhead) in the nerve
fiber layer (n) is strongly TULP1-positive. (F) Same section
as in (E) labeled with anti-blue cone opsin, with
DAPI-stained nuclei. Differentiating cones (arrows) are
labeled with both anti-TULP1 (E) and anti-blue cone opsin.
Note displaced blue cone opsinpositive cell (arrowhead) in
the nerve fiber layer (n). (G) Central retina illustrating
layer of columnar photoreceptors (p), all of which are TULP1-positive,
particularly the differentiating cones. Note TULP1-positive cell
(arrowhead) in the nerve fiber layer (n). (H)
Section labeled with anti-TULP1, with DAPI-stained nuclei. Note
TULP1-positive cells (arrowheads) in the nerve fiber layer
(n). (I) Same section as in (H) labeled with
anti-recoverin, with DAPI-stained nuclei. Note colocalization of
recoverin and TULP1 in the same cells (arrowheads) in the
nerve fiber layer (n). Magnification, (A, B,
C, E, F, G, I)
x193; (D) x290; (H) x193.
|
|
In the retina at fetal week 17.4 and later, there was a prominent layer
of differentiating photoreceptors in both central and peripheral
retina, all of which were reactive for both TULP1 (Figs. 2D
2E
2F
2G)
and recoverin. Among these cells, some had large, prominent cell bodies
that protruded into the subretinal space (Figs. 2D
2E)
and a basal
process typical of immature cones.16
These differentiating
cones were intensely positive for TULP1, and at 11 weeks and later,
some were reactive for blue cone opsin (Fig. 2F)
. The first cones
labeled with anti-red/green cone opsin were found at age 15.4 weeks,
and they were also strongly positive for TULP1 (not shown). By 17.4
weeks, all cones in the centralmost retina were intensely
TULP1-positive (Fig. 2G)
. At this time, the differentiating rods around
the developing fovea formed a layer vitread to the differentiating
cones, but these early rods were only weakly reactive for TULP1 (Fig. 2E) .
A second group of TULP1-positive cells was found in the developing
retinas at fetal age 15.4 weeks to 1 month after birth. These cells lay
in the nerve fiber and ganglion cell layers and were often found in
small groups, particularly in the peripheral retina (Figs. 2E
2G
2H)
.
These cells were larger than the neighboring ganglion cells and
were round or oval with numerous fine processes. The location and
morphology of these cells suggested initially that they were
astrocytes, and double labeling was therefore performed with anti-TULP1
and anti-GFAP. Although numerous stellate astrocytes were labeled
with anti-GFAP, the TULP1-reactive cells in the innermost retina were
GFAP-negative. The multipolar TULP1-reactive cells were labeled with
anti-recoverin (Fig. 2I)
, and some were reactive with anti-blue cone
opsin (Fig. 2F)
, but not with anti-red/green cone opsin or
anti-rhodopsin. Similar recoverin-positive multipolar cells have been
described in the ganglion cell and nerve fiber layers of fetal human
retinas,17
although cone-specific markers were not used in
that study.
Because of the optic disc abnormalities observed in young human RP
patients with TULP1 mutations, it was anticipated that
ganglion cells and the optic nerve head might show immunolabeling with
anti-TULP1. Scattered cells in the ganglion cell layer were weakly
TULP1-positive from 11 weeks onward (Figs. 1F
2E
2G)
; however, they
were always less intensely labeled than the differentiating
photoreceptors in the same area. In adult retinas, a few ganglion cells
and inner nuclear layer cells were also weakly TULP1-positive (Figs. 1A 1D)
. The optic nerve head and astrocytes, evaluated with anti-GFAP,
were consistently negative for TULP1 (not shown).
Postnatal Human Retinas
The pattern of TULP1-labeling in the newborn (3 day and 1 month)
retinas was essentially the same as in the adult. Strong
TULP1-reactivity was found in the cone and rod inner segments, somata,
and synapses, and a few inner nuclear layer and ganglion cells were
weakly labeled. In the periphery, TULP1- and recoverin-positive cells
were present in the nerve fiber layer, and a few of these were reactive
for blue cone opsin. The optic nerve head and astrocytes were
TULP1-negative.
 |
Discussion
|
|---|
The present study documents the localization of TULP1 in
developing and adult human retinas. The finding of very early
expression of TULP1 by retinal neuroblasts at 8.4 fetal weeks (the
earliest age examined) suggests a fundamental role for TULP1 in retinal
differentiation. Further, the observation that all retinal neuroblasts
were TULP1-positive indicates that this protein may be involved in
development of both photoreceptors and inner retinal neurons.
TULP1-labeling was strongest in developing cones, including displaced
blue cones in the nerve fiber layer, whereas in adult retinas the
labeling was somewhat less intense in cones than in rods. The
significance of these cone/rod differences is unknown but suggests that
both populations of photoreceptors are probably affected early in
development of the retina in RP patients with mutations in the
TULP1 gene. In agreement, recent studies of patients
homozygous for a TULP1 mutation11
and
TULP1-/- mice13
have
documented early degenerative changes in the cones as well as the rods.
Many genes associated with human RP are expressed solely in
photoreceptors, the cells that usually undergo primary
degeneration.18
Older patients with RP often show optic
disc changes consistent with secondary degeneration of ganglion cells
and their axons.19
Sahly et al.12
found
tub expression in ganglion cells during mouse retinal
embryogenesis but mainly in photoreceptors in postnatal and adult mice.
The observation that the Dominican Republic patients with RP who are
homozygous for a splice-site mutation in the TULP1 gene can
show optic disc degeneration in the first decade of life raised the
question of whether TULP1 is expressed in inner retinal
neurons as well as photoreceptors during development.11
Findings from the present immunolabeling study favor this supposition,
because TULP1-labeling was detected in differentiating ganglion cells
early in retinal development and in a few of these cells in adult
retinas.
The absence of TULP1-labeling in cone and rod outer segments
found here in human retinas and also in wild-type mouse
retinas6
13
suggests that this protein does not play a
role in phototransduction. It is critical to identify the genes
regulated by TULP1 as a possible transcription factor7
to
understand the degenerative changes in photoreceptors and inner retinal
neurons in RP caused by mutations in the TULP1 gene.
 |
Acknowledgements
|
|---|
The authors thank the scientists listed in the Methods
section for providing antibodies, and Andra Erickson for help with the
sectioning.
 |
Footnotes
|
|---|
Supported by the Foundation Fighting Blindness, Hunt Valley, Maryland (AHM and PMN); the Paul and Evanina Bell Mackall Foundation Trust, New York, New York (AHM); National Institutes of Health Grants EY04536 and EY01730 (AEH); the Kayser Award (AEH); and AXYS Pharmaceuticals (PMN).
Submitted for publication November 19, 1999; revised January 6, 2000, and February 7, 2000; accepted February 15, 2000.
Commercial relationships policy: N.
Corresponding author: Ann H. Milam, Scheie Eye Institute, 51 North 39th Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104. annmilam{at}mail.med.upenn.edu
 |
References
|
|---|
-
Heckenlively, J, Chang, B, Erway, L, et al (1995) Mouse model for Usher syndrome: linkage mapping suggests homology to Usher type I reported at human chromosome 11p15 Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 92,11100-11104[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Ohlemiller, K, Hughes, R, Lett, J, et al (1997) Progression of cochlear and retinal degeneration in the tubby (rd5) mouse Audiol Neurootol 2,175-185[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
NobenTrauth, K, Naggert, J, North, M, Nishina, P. (1996) A candidate gene for the mouse mutation tubby Nature 380,534-538[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
North, M, Naggert, J, Yan, Y, et al (1997) Molecular characterization of TUB, TULP1, and TULP2, members of the novel tubby gene family and their possible relation to ocular diseases Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 94,3128-3133[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Nishina, P, North, M, Ikeda, A, et al (1998) Molecular characterization of a novel tubby gene family member, TULP3, in mouse and humans Genomics 54,215-220[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
Ikeda, S, He, W, Ikeda, A, et al (1999) Cell-specific expression of tubby gene family members (tub, TULP1, 2, and 3) in the retina Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 40,2706-2712[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Boggon, TJ, Shan, W-S, Santagata, S, et al (1999) Implication of tubby proteins as transcription factors by structure-based functional analysis Science 286,2119-2125[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Banerjee, P, Kleyn, P, Knowles, J, et al (1998) TULP1 mutation in two extended Dominican kindreds with autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa Nat Genet 18,177-179[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
Gu, S, Lennon, A, Li, Y, et al (1998) Tubby-like protein-1 mutations in autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa Lancet 35,1103-1104
-
Hagstrom, S, North, M, Nishina, P, et al (1998) Recessive mutations in the gene encoding the tubby-like protein TULP1 in patients with retinitis pigmentosa Nature 18,174-176
-
Lewis, C, Batlle, I, Batlle, K, et al (1999) Tubby-like protein 1 homozygous splice-site mutation causes early-onset severe retinal degeneration Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 40,2106-2114[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Sahly, I, Gogat, K, Kobetz, A, et al (1998) Prominent neuronal-specific tub gene expression in cellular targets of tubby mice mutation Hum Mol Genet 7,1437-1447[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Hagstrom, SA, Duyao, M, North, MA, Li, T. (1999) Retinal degeneration in tulp1-/- mice: vesicular accumulation in the interphotoreceptor matrix Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 40,2795-2802[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Li, Z-Y, Kljavin, IJ, Milam, AH (1995) Rod photoreceptor neurite sprouting in retinitis pigmentosa J Neurosci 15,5429-5438[Abstract]
-
Hendrickson, A. (1992) A morphological comparison of foveal development in man and monkey Eye 6,136-144
-
Bumsted, K, Hendrickson, A. (1999) Distribution and development of short-wavelength cones differ between Macaca monkey and human fovea J Comp Neurol 403,502-516[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
Yan, X, Wiechmann, A. (1997) Early expression of recoverin in a unique population of neurons in the human retina Anat Embryol 195,51-63[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
Milam, AH, Li, Z-Y, Fariss, RN (1998) Histopathology of the human retina in retinitis pigmentosa Prog Retinal Eye Res 17,175-205[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-
Stone, JL, Barlow, WE, Humayun, MS, et al (1992) Morphometric analysis of macular photoreceptors and ganglion cells in retinas with retinitis pigmentosa Arch Ophthalmol 110,1634-1639[Abstract/Free Full Text]
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. R. Roberts, A. Hendrickson, C. R. McGuire, and T. A. Reh
Retinoid X Receptor {gamma} Is Necessary to Establish the S-opsin Gradient in Cone Photoreceptors of the Developing Mouse Retina
Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci.,
August 1, 2005;
46(8):
2897 - 2904.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
S. A. Hagstrom, M. Adamian, M. Scimeca, B. S. Pawlyk, G. Yue, and T. Li
A Role for the Tubby-Like Protein 1 in Rhodopsin Transport
Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci.,
August 1, 2001;
42(9):
1955 - 1962.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|