|
|
||||||||
B-Crystallin in Lens Development and Muscle Integrity: A Gene Knockout Approach
1 From the National Eye Institute and the 3 Pathology Section, Office of Research Services, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland; the 5 Anatomy Department, University of Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany; and the 6 Eye Research Institute, Oakland University, Rochester, Michigan.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
B-crystallin (
B) in the developing lens and
its importance in lens structure and function.
METHODS. Gene targeting in embryonic stem cells was used to generate mouse lines
in which the
B gene and its protein product were absent. Gene
structure and expression were characterized by genomic Southern blot,
immunoblot, and Northern blot analyses, and two-dimensional gel
electrophoresis. The gene knockout mice were screened for cataract with
slit lamp biomicroscopy, and dissected lenses were examined with
dark-field microscopy. Lenses and other tissues were analyzed by
standard histology and immunohistochemistry. Chaperone activity was
determined by heating lens homogenate supernatants and measuring
absorbance changes.
RESULTS. In an unexpected result, lenses in the
B gene knockout mice
developed normally and were remarkably similar to wild-type mouse
lenses. All the other crystallins were present. The thermal stability
of a lens homogenate supernatant was mildly compromised, and when
oxidatively stressed in vivo with hyperbaric oxygen, the knockout
lenses reacted similarly to wild type. In targeting the
B gene, the
adjacent HSPB2 gene, which is not expressed in
the lens, was also disrupted. Loss of
B and/or HSPB2 function leads
to degeneration of some skeletal muscles.
CONCLUSIONS.
B is not essential for normal development of a transparent lens in
the mouse, and therefore is more dispensable to the lens than the
closely related
A-crystallin. It may play a small role in
maintaining transparency throughout life.
B and/or the closely
related HSPB2 is required to maintain muscle cell integrity in some
skeletal muscles.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-crystallins are members of the small heat
shock family of proteins that, together with the ß- and
-crystallins, comprise the major water-soluble proteins of the
vertebrate ocular lens. The two
-crystallin proteins,
A- and
B-crystallin (hereafter known as
A and
B), are approximately
60% identical with one another and share many common properties in
vitro, such as autokinase activity,1
interaction with
cytoskeletal proteins,2
3
4
5
DNA binding,6
and
the ability to act as molecular chaperones.7
However,
there are differences between the two proteins. Although both
-crystallins show sequence similarity to small heat shock proteins
(sHSPs), only
B is inducible by stress.8
9
Also,
A
is expressed at very high levels in the lens and is found in trace
amounts in only a few nonlenticular tissues,10
11
12
whereas
B, although it is most highly expressed in the lens, is found at
significant levels in a number of tissues.13
14
15
B is
particularly abundant in adult heart and skeletal muscle, and its
message has been detected very early in the developing mouse heart and
somites.16
17
The
-crystallins were originally thought to be lens-specific
structural proteins. However, the discoveries that
B is expressed
outside the lens and that it is stress inducible have brought broader
attention to the
-crystallins and to their potential usefulness for
elucidating the functions and evolution of stress proteins. In
addition, there is a growing list of human diseases in which
B has
been shown to be misexpressed, mislocalized, or otherwise
involved.18
One disease, an autosomal dominant
desmin-related myopathy, was recently shown to result from a missense
mutation in the human
B gene. This disorder is characterized by
adult-onset muscular weakness, cardiomyopathy, and
cataracts.19
20
These clinical findings and the
observation that
B is expressed very early in the developing heart
and skeletal muscles suggest a critical physiological role for
B.
To elucidate the in vivo functions of
-crystallins, we generated
mice with targeted disruptions of the genes that encode the
A and
B proteins. We previously reported that homozygous
A knockout
mice have smaller lenses than those of wild-type littermates and that
progressive opacifications develop in the knockout lenses that
apparently result, at least in part, from the presence in lens fiber
cells of inclusion bodies that contain high concentrations of
B.21
Herein, we present the initial characterization of
mice with a targeted deletion that disrupts both the
B gene and the
adjacent gene, HSPB2, which is an ancient duplication of
B.22
The existence of the HSPB2 gene, which
lies approximately 1 kb upstream of
B, was reported after we
produced the
B knockout mice. Similar to
B, HSPB2 is expressed in
skeletal and cardiac muscles where it is often localized to the Z lines
and has also been shown to associate with and activate myotonic
dystrophy protein kinase.23
Unlike
B, HSPB2 is not
expressed in the lens.22
Mice without both
B and HSPB2
are surprisingly viable and fertile and have no obvious perinatal
defects, and their lenses remain as transparent as those of wild-type
mice. However, as they become older,
B/HSPB2 homozygous
knockout mice show postural defects and other health problems that
appear to stem from progressive myopathy.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
B/HSPB2 Gene Knockout Mice
phage clone spanning approximately 16 kb of the
B/HSPB2 locus was isolated from a 129Sv mouse genomic
library (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA). A targeting vector (Fig. 1A)
was constructed by ligating two restriction fragments: a 3-kb
BamHI fragment, encompassing a portion of exon 3 and the 3'
flanking sequences of the
B gene and a 5-kb
NotI/NarI fragment encompassing a portion of exon
2 and the 3' flanking sequences of the HSPB2 gene, into the
vector pPNT24
on opposite sides of the phosphoglycerate
kinase-neomycin phosphotransferase (PGK/neo) gene
cassette (Fig. 1A)
. The targeting vector also included the
PGK/herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase
(PGK/HSVtk) gene cassette for negative selection.
Electroporation of J1 embryonic stem cells, selection and screening of
targeted cells, and blastocyst microinjection were performed as
previously described.21
Two independent embryonic stem
(ES) cell clones were used to generate two lines of knockout mice. DNAs
from ES cells and knockout mice were analyzed by PCR, using primers
spanning, but not encoded within, the shorter arm of the knockout
vector and by Southern blot, using the 3-kb BamHI fragment
(Fig. 1A
; triple line) as a probe. Once stable lines of knockout mice
were established, a simpler PCR protocol was used for genotyping. PCR
using three primers, 5'-TAGCTTAATAATCTGGGCCA-3',
5'-GGAGTTCCACAGGAAGTACC-3', and 5'-TGGAAGGATTGGAGCTACGG-3', in a 4:1:1
molar ratio produced a 310-bp product with the wild-type allele and a
600-bp product with the knockout allele. All work with mice conformed
to the ARVO Statement for the Use of Animals in Ophthalmic and Vision
Research.
|
B-crystallin
(a gift from Joseph Horwitz, Jules Stein Eye Institute, University of
California at Los Angeles School of Medicine). Protocols for antibody
incubation and detection have been described.21
Northern Blot to Detect HSPB2 mRNA
Northern blot analysis was performed using standard
protocols.25
RNA was extracted from lens, heart, soleus,
plantaris, and gastrocnemius muscles of 16- to 17-week-old knockout and
wild-type mice. Total RNA (10 µg for lens, heart and gastrocnemius; 5
µg for soleus and plantaris) was used, and before blots were formed,
a gel lane containing RNA size markers (Life Technologies, Rockville,
MD) was removed and stained. The blot was probed with a 3-kb
HpaI/XbaI genomic fragment (Fig. 1A
; double
line), spanning the entire HSPB2 gene and approximately 0.8
kb of its 3' flanking sequence, and then reprobed with a ß-actin
probe (Oncor, Rockville, MD).
Slit Lamp Biomicroscopy
Mouse eyes were dilated with eye drops containing 1%
tropicamide followed several minutes later by eye drops containing
2.5% phenylephrine hydrochloride. Approximately 15 minutes later, the
mice were anesthetized with an intraperitoneal injection of 0.015 to
0.017 ml 2.5% 2,2,2-tribromoethanol per gram body weight and
immediately examined with a slit lamp. The slit illumination was always
at a 45° angle to the observation optics.
Histology
Eyes were removed, gently pierced in the limbal region, and
fixed in 4% buffered glutaraldehyde for 20 minutes, followed by 4%
buffered formaldehyde or 4% buffered formaldehyde alone. For a milder
treatment, eyes were occasionally fixed in 4% buffered
paraformaldehyde for 25 minutes, rinsed for 30 minutes in PBS, and
placed in 80% ethanol for several days. They were embedded in
methacrylate or paraffin, sectioned, and stained with hematoxylin and
eosin (H&E). Hindlimbs and spine regions were fixed in 4% buffered
formaldehyde, decalcified, embedded in methacrylate or paraffin,
sectioned, and stained with H&E. Tongue was similarly processed, but
the decalcification step was omitted.
Protection from Heat-Induced Denaturation Assay
Pairs of lenses from wild-type, heterozygous and homozygous
B
knockout, and homozygous
A knockout mice were disrupted in 1 ml of
buffer (0.1 M sodium phosphate [pH 7.4]; 0.1 M sodium chloride). The
homogenate was centrifuged for 10 minutes at 4°C at
14,000g in a microfuge. The supernatant was removed and the
pellet was rehomogenized with another 1 ml buffer. After
centrifugation, each supernatant was pooled with the first. Protein
concentrations were determined by BCA assay (Pierce) and samples were
diluted to 3.1 mg/ml protein. Samples were placed in a
temperature-controlled (54°C or 63°C) spectrophotometer cuvette
holder at time 0, and absorbance at 360 nm was monitored.
Two-Dimensional Gel Electrophoresis
Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and image analysis were
performed, essentially as previously described.26
Briefly,
lenses frozen on dry ice immediately after dissection and maintained at
-70°C were thawed in a protease inhibitor mix (P8340; Sigma, St.
Louis, MO) then homogenized in 9 M urea, 2% NP40, 10 mM dithiothreitol
(DTT), 2% ampholytes (Resolyte 3.5-10), and centrifuged at
16,000g for 20 minutes. The supernatant was run in the
first-dimension isoelectric focusing strip, using dry-strip gels (pH
310 nonlinear; Immobiline DryStrip; Amersham Pharmacia Biotech,
Piscataway, NJ), and in the second dimension, using 15% to 18%.SDS
polyacrylamide gradient gel. Gels were stained with Coomassie blue,
cleared with water, scanned on a personal densitometer (Molecular
Dynamics, Sunnyvale, CA), and analyzed by computer (Phoretix, ver. 5.0;
Phoretix International, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK) software.
Immunohistochemistry
Tissues used for immunohistochemistry were fixed in 4% buffered
paraformaldehyde. Spine and hindlimb tissues were then decalcified. All
tissue preparations were embedded in paraffin and sectioned onto
silane-coated slides. Immunohistochemistry was performed using
immunoperoxidase reagents in avidin-biotin complex (ABC) and substrate
kits (Vectastain Universal Elite and VIP, respectively; Vector
Laboratories, Burlingame, CA), according to the manufacturers
instructions. Serial sections were immunostained, and, because mouse
monoclonal antibodies were being used with mouse tissues, one slide in
each experiment was run without any primary antibody, as a control for
nonspecific detection by the anti-mouse IgG secondary antibody. One
slide was also stained with H&E. Monoclonal antibodies against myosin
heavy chains, (MHC fast and MHC slow; Sigma) were used at 1:500
dilution, and the monoclonal antibody against desmin (Dako,
Carpinteria, CA) was used at dilutions of 1:20 to 1:75.
Transmission Electron Microscopy
Tongues were sliced with a razor blade into approximately 3-mm
cross-sections to aid penetration of fixative. The tongue sections and
soleus and extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscles dissected from
hindlimbs of knockout (53-week-old) and wild-type (57-week-old) mice,
were fixed in freshly prepared 2.5% glutaraldehyde and 2.5%
paraformaldehyde in 80 mM cacodylate buffer (pH 7.2). After fixation,
the tissues were equilibrated in cacodylate buffer for at least 24
hours and then postfixed with 2% OsO4 and
embedded in Epon (Roth, Karlsruhe, Germany). Ultrathin sections were
contrasted with lead citrate and uranyl acetate and examined with a
transmission electron microscope (EM 902; Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen,
Germany).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
B/HSPB2 Knockout Mice
B
gene and concomitantly the adjacent HSPB2 gene. All the
protein-coding sequences through the middle of the third and final exon
of
B and 1.6 kb of DNA encompassing the putative transcriptional
regulatory sequences for
B and HSPB2 as well as most of
the HSPB2 protein-coding sequences were eliminated in the
targeted chromosome. Genomic Southern blot analysis demonstrated the
expected rearrangements of the
B and HSPB2 genes in
heterozygous and homozygous knockout mice (Fig. 1B)
. Deletion of an
EcoRI site in the targeted allele resulted in an increase
from 9 to 13 kb of the probe-containing EcoRI fragment, and
replacement of the sHSP genes with the shorter
PGK/neo cassette decreased the size of the
probe-containing HpaI fragment from 18 to 15 kb. Western
blot analysis of soluble and insoluble proteins from the lens, the
tissue with the highest expression level of
B, confirmed that the
full-length form and two C-terminally truncated forms of
B were all
decreased in heterozygous and absent in homozygous knockout mice (Fig. 1C)
. Further evidence for the absence of
B is the absence of an
B
signal in immunoblots of skeletal muscle and heart (not shown) and the
loss of immunologic tolerance to
B as a self-antigen in knockout
mice (Igal Gery, personal communication, November 1996).
The closely linked HSPB2 gene was discovered subsequent to
the production of these knockout mice, and because available sequence
data22
suggested we had disrupted this gene also, Northern
blot analysis was performed to confirm this. Figure 1D
shows that
HSPB2 mRNA, which was previously detected in adult heart and
skeletal muscles but not in lenses of wild-type rats,22
was absent from heart and skeletal muscles of homozygous
B/HSPB2 knockout mice, but was present in wild-type mouse
muscle tissues, confirming that the HSPB2 gene, in addition
to the
B gene, was functionally inactivated. Figure 1D
also confirms
that HSPB2 is not expressed in the lenses of normal mice.
B/HSPB2-/- mice are born at nearly
normal Mendelian ratios from matings between heterozygous (+/-)
animals (20% of 200 such offspring were -/-). At birth, the knockout
mice exhibit no obvious mutant phenotypes.
Characterization of Lens Structure and Development
Analysis of lenses from 11-week-old mice revealed average lens
weights of 5.5 ± 0.2, 5.3 ± 0.2, and 5.1 ± 0.2 mg for
wild-type, heterozygous, and homozygous
B-crystallin/HSPB2 knockout mice, respectively.
Measurement of the equatorial and axial dimensions of whole eyes and
lenses from the same mice revealed no significant differences (not
shown). This is in stark contrast to
A knockout mice in which the
lens weight is reduced by approximately 30% and the axial and
equatorial dimensions are decreased by approximately
15%.21
The slit lamp micrographs (Figs. 2A
2B)
show little if any difference in light scattering between the
wild-type and knockout lenses. There is a basal level of light
scattering in the lenses of 129Sv mice that manifested itself in slit
lamp examination as an apparent opacity at the edge of the lens
opposite the slit illumination. This may have been due to the recently
discovered absence of the lens-specific beaded filament cytoskeletal
proteins, cp49 and filensin, in lenses of 129S strains of
mice.27
Age-matched knockout mice, particularly at older
ages, appear to have slightly more of this light scattering.
Examination of dissected lenses with dark-field illumination (Figs. 2C
2D)
confirms the similarly low light scattering in wild-type and
B
knockout lenses, which contrasts with the high degree of light
scattering in the
A knockout lenses. Histologic examination of
lenses revealed no obvious differences between wild-type and
B
knockout specimens (Fig. 3)
. In contrast, mice in which the closely related
A gene is disrupted
(Figs. 3E
3F)
show development of lens opacities before 7 weeks of
age, and histologic abnormalities even earlier,21
which
progress in severity with age (Figs. 2A
2C
2D)
.
|
|
B knockout
lenses, depending on the method of fixation used. Fixation with 4%
buffered formaldehyde alone (Figs. 3G
3H
3I
3J)
caused an invagination of the
lens at the equator that was similar in wild-type (Fig. 3G) and
B
knockout (Fig. 3I)
mice. When eyes were fixed with 4% buffered
glutaraldehyde for 20 minutes followed by 4% buffered formaldehyde,
small vacuoles were observed in the outer cortex of lenses from both
wild-type (Figs. 3K
3L)
and
B knockout (Figs. 3M
3N
3O
3P)
mice. Samples
fixed with buffered formaldehyde alone (Figs. 3G
3H
3I
3J)
or formaldehyde
for 25 minutes followed by 80% ethanol (not shown) did not exhibit
these vacuoles. Because these vacuoles appeared with only one method of
tissue fixation and independently of the presence or absence of
B,
they may have been artifactual. Cytoplasmic inclusion bodies present in
the lens nuclei of
A knockout mice (Fig. 3F)
were not observed in
the lenses of
B knockout mice (Fig. 3D)
. These results clearly
demonstrate that the lens can much more easily accommodate the loss of
B function than it can the loss of
A function. Because the
HSPB2 gene is not expressed in the lens22
(Fig. 1D)
, its disruption is not expected to affect the lens.
Crystallin Expression in Knockout Lenses
Because the lenses of
B knockout mice appear normal and
transparent, we suspected that the distribution of other major
crystallins was not significantly affected by the absence of
B.
Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of lens proteins (Fig. 4)
followed by image analysis, which detects spots too faint to be seen
by the naked eye, revealed that all the major and minor crystallin
spots present in wild-type mice, except, of course, for
B and
modified forms of
B, were also present in the knockout mice. There
were no new or additional crystallin spots detected in the knockout
mice.
B, its mono- and di-phosphorylated forms, and the
phosphorylated and unphosphorylated forms of the
B C-terminal
truncation (amino acids 171 to 175 removed) are all absent in the
B
knockout lens.
|
B is an sHSP and molecular chaperone, we investigated
whether lenses without
B were more susceptible to damage. The
ability of lens proteins to resist heat-induced denaturation was
studied (Fig. 5)
. When the soluble fraction of lens homogenate from wild-type mice was
heated to 54°C, there was little increase in turbidity of the
solution over the 60-minute experiment, indicating that most proteins
remained soluble and that these lenses have thermal protective
capacity. The lens homogenate supernatant without
B showed a slow
increase in turbidity (and therefore, protein denaturation) beginning
at 30 minutes and reached twice the level in wild-type lenses at 60
minutes, suggesting that the overall protective activity in the
B
knockout lens was mildly impaired (Fig. 5A)
. When the lens homogenate
supernatants were heated to 63°C, the difference between wild-type
and
B lenses became more pronounced, with turbidity of the knockout
homogenate supernatant reaching three times that of wild type at 60
minutes (Fig. 5B)
. There was still a high degree of thermal protection
in the
B knockout lenses compared with
A knockout lenses, which
exhibited almost no protective capacity, with much of the protein
precipitating after 15 minutes (Fig. 5B)
.
|
B knockout lenses to resist
oxidative stress. Exposure of humans and animals to hyperbaric oxygen
has been shown to induce an increased level of lens nuclear light
scattering or nuclear cataract.28
29
30
31
Repeated exposure of
mice to hyperbaric oxygen (2.53.2 atmospheres of
O2 for 2.53 hours per exposure, three exposures
per week) over a period of 5.5 months induced increased lens nuclear
light scattering equally well in wild-type and knockout mice (not
shown), suggesting that in vivo,
B does not play a major role in
protecting the lens against oxidative damage. This is in agreement with
the results of Kannan et al.,32
who demonstrated that the
level of reduced glutathione (GSH) in lenses without
B is
equal to that in wild-type lenses, whereas lenses without
A exhibit
a severe decrease in GSH level, and with the results of Andley et
al.,33
who demonstrated that
B is significantly less
effective than
A in protecting lens cells against stress.
Development of lens opacity in
A knockout mice at an early age, even
in the absence of added oxidative stress, precludes similar hyperbaric
oxygen experiments from providing useful data on
A knockout mice.
Health Problems in Aging Knockout Mice
The growth curves of male and female knockout mice paralleled
those of wild-type 129Sv until approximately 40 weeks of age (data not
shown); but thereafter, the knockout mice consistently lost weight and
eventually lost most of their body fat. The mice also displayed a
hunched posture resulting from development of a severe curvature of the
spine (kyphosis) that could be readily observed in radiograms of
12-month-old mice (Fig. 6)
. Histologic examination of the hunched mice revealed degenerative
osteoarthritis of the intervertebral facet joints. Although not
uncommon in much older wild-type mice, this process appears to be
greatly accelerated in the knockout mice. Because both
B and HSPB2
are expressed in muscle cells, we suspected that the underlying cause
of the observed kyphosis was related to altered function of muscles
associated with the axial skeleton. In histologic examination of
65-week-old knockout mice exhibiting the hunched posture, the heart
appeared normal (not shown), but severe degeneration of some skeletal
muscles was readily apparent (Fig. 7)
with the most severely affected muscles being in the posterior tongue
(Figs. 7B 7D)
, head, and surrounding the axial skeleton (Figs. 7F
7
H). Limb muscles were affected to a lesser extent (not shown). None of
these degenerative changes was observed in the skeletal muscles of
age-matched heterozygous (not shown) or wild-type mice (Figs. 7A 7C
7E
7G)
.
|
|
Because the muscle degeneration in older mice was severe and apparently the consequence of chronic muscular dystrophy, we examined knockout mice at several younger ages (not shown). At 7 weeks of age muscles appeared relatively normal, exhibiting only very minimal axial muscular dystrophy. By 20 weeks of age, the axial muscular dystrophy had progressed in severity, exhibiting some occasional fibrosis, fatty infiltration, and myositis, suggesting the chronic nature of this condition. By this age, muscles of the head were also affected, and the diaphragm and select hindlimb muscles (e.g., the soleus) were mildly affected. At 40 weeks of age, the accumulated damage to the axial muscles was more severe, with fibrosis and fatty infiltrates more pronounced. Muscles of the head, particularly those of the hyoid apparatus, showed marked degeneration. The soleus muscle in the hindlimb was moderately affected. At this age the mice began to lose body mass and exhibit a hunched posture. At all ages examined, the most severely affected muscle cells were generally located adjacent to bone or at tendinous insertions and occasionally deep within muscle bundles.
Ultrastructure of the Degenerating Muscle Cells
Electron microscopy revealed degenerative changes at the
ultrastructural level (Fig. 8)
. The appearance of amorphous, flocculent, electron-opaque material
(FEOM) interspersed between myofibrils was seen in mildly affected
cells (Fig. 8
, arrows), probably signifying early events in the
degenerative process. A mildly affected tongue cell (Fig. 8A)
with only
a small area of FEOM was adjacent to cells with relatively normal
appearances. As the degenerative process progressed in both tongue
(Figs. 8A
8C
8D)
and soleus (Fig. 8E)
, the relative proportion of
FEOM increased within the cell, with a concomitant loss of myofibrils
(black arrowheads) until there were few, if any, myofibrils remaining
(Figs. 8C
8E) . Consistent with histologic findings (Fig. 7)
, large
vacuoles (identified by asterisks) were present in the later stages of
muscle cell degeneration in both tongue (Fig. 8D)
and soleus (Fig. 8E) .
Degenerative changes were not observed in EDL muscles from the same
knockout mice (not shown). None of the degenerative changes observed in
muscles of knockout mice was seen in the corresponding tissues of
age-matched wild-type mice (Fig. 8B)
.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A- and
B-crystallins, members of the family of sHSPs, are
both expressed at high levels in the vertebrate lens. Whereas
A is
expressed at very low levels in a few nonlenticular
tissues,11
34
B is expressed at significant levels in
many other tissues13
14
and, as the family name implies,
is induced by heat and other stresses.8
9
18
A point
mutation in the
A gene has been linked to autosomal dominant
cataract in humans,35
and similarly, a point mutation in
the
B gene has been linked to a desmin-related myopathy with
associated cataract.20
Although
A and
B share a high degree of homology and form
heteromultimeric aggregates,36
37
there appear to be
significant differences between these proteins. In vitro,
B has been
shown to be less thermodynamically stable,38
more
susceptible to heat-induced conformational changes,39
a
less effective chaperone,40
41
and more preferentially
dissociated from native
-crystallin aggregates by chaotropic
agents42
than
A. Unlike
A,
B does not exhibit
markedly increased autokinase activity when dissociated to the
tetrameric state.43
In cell culture,
B has been shown
to be less effective than
A in preventing lens epithelial cells from
ultraviolet light or staurosporine-induced apoptosis,33
and addition of
B, but not
A, to cultured lens cells has been
shown to induce morphologic changes reminiscent of differentiating
fiber cells.44
We have studied the roles of the two
-crystallins in vivo by
removing them by gene targeting in the mouse. Previously, we showed
that the absence of
A results in microphthalmia, decreased lens size
and weight, cataract formation before the age of 7 weeks, formation of
B-containing cytoplasmic inclusion bodies in lens fiber cells by 4
weeks of age, and a major shift of lenticular
B from the soluble to
the insoluble phase.21
It is therefore possible that a
primary function of
A is maintaining the solubility of high
concentrations of
B in lens cells. In the present study, we deleted
the
B and the closely related HSPB2 genes from the mouse.
In contrast to the lens devastation observed in the
A knockout
mouse, the lenses of the
B knockout mice were remarkably similar to
those of wild-type mice and remained so throughout life, suggesting
that
A is more important in lens development and maintenance of lens
transparency than
B.
The sizes of
B knockout lenses were the same as those of wild type,
and the lens mass of knockout mice was only approximately 7% less than
wild type, compared with the approximately 30% mass reduction and 15%
reduction axial and equatorial dimensions of the
A knockout lenses.
It is unclear whether this slight mass reduction is due to decreased
cell number or a decreased average mass per cell in the knockout
lenses. Despite the small difference in mass, the lenses of
B
knockout and wild-type mice appeared very similar in gross morphology
and histologically, and although slit lamp examination of the
B
knockout lenses often produced slightly more basal light scattering
than did wild-type lenses,
B knockout and wild-type lenses dissected
and directly compared in dark-field illumination exhibited a similar
amount of light scattering. Such discrepancies between slit lamp
examinations and examinations of dissected lenses have been previously
documented in mice.45
In both slit lamp and dark field,
light scattering was far less in lenses of
B knockout mice than
those of
A knockout mice.
It has recently been reported that lenses from 129Sv mice do not have
the lens-specific beaded filament cytoskeletal proteins cp49 and
filensin, as a result of a mutation in the cp49 gene.27
This deficit may be responsible, at least in part, for the basal level
of light scattering seen in the lenses of both wild-type and
B
knockout mice that are in the mouse 129Sv background. The absence of
this cytoskeletal component may also contribute to the vacuoles
observed in the outer cortex of lenses fixed with glutaraldehyde
followed by formaldehyde (Figs. 3K
3L
3M
3N
3O
3P)
, regardless of whether these
vacuoles are true reflections of the in vivo condition or artifacts of
tissue preparation resulting from a weakened cytoskeleton.
A key feature of the cataract in
A knockout mice is the presence of
cytoplasmic inclusion bodies containing mainly
B,21
indicating that the presence of
A is essential to maintaining the
solubility of
B in lens nuclear and inner cortical fiber cells. In
the absence of
B, we saw no indication of inclusion bodies
containing
A, suggesting that
A is more stable in the lens milieu
than
B and does not require its aggregation partner,
B, to remain
in solution. This apparent propensity of
B to form inclusion bodies
at high concentration is of particular interest, because
B has been
found to be a constituent of inclusion bodies in a variety of
pathologic conditions46
in which
B is upregulated,
including Rosenthal fibers in Alexander disease,47
cortical Lewy bodies in Lewy body disease,48
Mallory
bodies in alcoholic liver disease,48
and Alzheimer disease
plaques and neurofibrillary tangles.49
50
51
The overall chaperone activity in the
B knockout lens was only
mildly diminished compared with that of the
A knockout lens, as
demonstrated by protection against heat-induced aggregation of proteins
in a lens homogenate supernatant. The thermal protection assay has
recently been shown to give results comparable to other types of
chaperone assays.41
Contributing to the severely decreased
chaperone activity in
A knockout lenses, compared with
B knockout
lenses, may be the weaker chaperone activity of
B compared with that
of
A41
and the fact that in
A knockout lenses not
only is the
A absent, but a sizable portion of the
B is in the
insoluble phase and therefore is also absent from the lens homogenate
supernatant used for the assay.21
Hyperbaric oxygen
treatment of mice, used to oxidatively stress lenses in vivo, showed no
difference in loss of lens transparency between
B knockout and
wild-type mice. This is consistent with the relatively normal chaperone
activity in the
B knockout lenses and the relatively normal levels
of GSH in lenses of
B knockout mice at all ages.32
Although the lens seems unaffected by the absence of
B and
HSPB2, this mutation causes a severe phenotype in older mice
that is characterized by hunched posture, loss of body mass after 40
weeks of age, and severe muscle cell degeneration, but in only some
muscles. Because both
B and HSPB2 are expressed in skeletal
muscle23
52
and because both genes were disrupted in this
knockout mouse, we cannot ascribe this phenotype specifically to either
of the proteins; therefore, the muscle phenotype observed may result
from the absence of either or both of these closely related sHSPs.
Expression of
B in skeletal muscle is highest in the most oxidative,
slow-twitch type I muscle cells, intermediate in fast-twitch type IIA
cells, and lowest in the glycolytic, fast-twitch type IIB muscle
cells,15
53
consistent with its role as a stress protein,
and has been shown to colocalize with desmin at the Z
bands.54
The presence of muscle cell degeneration in the
cell type Icontaining soleus but not in the type II plantaris or EDL
suggests, but does not prove, that the oxidative type I muscle cells,
which normally would contain the highest levels of
B, are the
degenerating cells. Attempts to identify the degenerating muscle cell
type by immunostaining with antibodies for fast- or slow-twitch myosin
heavy chains were unsuccessful, with the degenerating cells staining
for neither type (data not shown). This could have been due to loss of
the myosin heavy chain antigen in the severely degenerated muscle
cells. Indeed, in a French family with desmin-related myopathy caused
by a point mutation in
B,20
the muscles contained cells
with a "rubbed-out" appearance when stained for either myosin
adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) activity or oxidative activity,
suggesting the loss of myosin in these cells.19
Vacuoles
with irregular edges were also observed. These anomalies were found
exclusively in type I fibers.19
In the French desmin-related myopathy,19
20
55
a mutant
B protein is present that becomes insoluble and forms dense
electron-opaque bodies in affected muscle cells.20
The
R120G mutant form of
B in this family was shown in vitro to adopt an
irregular structure, have drastically reduced chaperone function, and
be found in the insoluble material after chaperone
assays.56
This is quite different from the situation in
our
B knockout mice, in which the
B was simply absent. In this
case, there was no mutant protein with abnormal activity to interfere
with cellular processes; thus, we were looking purely at the effect of
deletion of the normal protein(s) from the cell. In this regard, some
of the anomalies found in our knockout mice are similar to those found
in the French family: emaciation, difficulty swallowing, abnormal gait,
weakness of muscles in the neck and trunk,19
20
and
increased immunohistochemical staining for desmin in severely affected
muscle cells (not shown), suggesting that the loss of normal
B
function may contribute to both phenotypes.
As stated earlier, we cannot rule out the possibility that the other deleted gene, HSPB2, may be responsible for the observed muscle phenotype. HSPB2, also known as myotonic dystrophy protein kinase binding protein (MKBP), has been shown to activate myotonic dystrophy protein kinase (DMPK) and protect it from heat-induced inactivation23 and is upregulated in myotonic dystrophy. Similar to our knockout mice, mice without DMPK show age-related changes in head and neck muscle fibers57 and late-onset, progressive skeletal myopathy, with elevated muscle fiber degeneration and fibrosis.58 It therefore seems plausible that the absence of HSPB2/MKBP contributes to the observed phenotype by failing to activate DMPK.
Similar to
B, HSPB2 has been localized to the Z lines in skeletal
muscle, suggesting that in addition to its role of activating DMPK, it
may also play a more direct role in stabilizing the sarcomeric
structure.23
However, HSPB2, with its aggregation partner
HSPB3, has been shown in muscle cells to form oligomeric complexes that
are separate from the complexes formed by
B, HSP25, and HSP20. Thus,
although they colocalize at Z lines, the two types of sHSP complexes
may have different protective functions there52
and may
both be essential for maintenance of sarcomeric structure in oxidative
muscle cells.
Because
B is expressed at high levels very early in embryonic heart
development, and both
B and HSPB2 are expressed in the fully formed
heart, we originally suspected that the gene knockout would cause
cardiac problems resulting in embryonic or neonatal lethality. We were
surprised to observe that the hearts of knockout mice appeared
histologically normal, even at older ages, and functioned sufficiently
in mice living in a controlled animal facility environment. However,
further studies of cardiac function under a variety of conditions are
being conducted by collaborators with cardiology expertise.
In summary, we have shown that
B-crystallin and HSPB2 are not
essential for viability or reproduction of the laboratory mouse,
B
is not essential for proper lens development, and
B and/or HSPB2 is
essential to maintaining integrity of some skeletal muscles. Our data
suggesting that
B contributes significantly less to lens development
and function than
A agree with recent evidence that
A is a better
chaperone than
B,41
that
A can protect lens cells
better than
B,33
and that loss of
A leads to a
severe decrease in the reducing capacity within the lens, as measured
by GSH level, whereas loss of
B has no effect on GSH
level.32
This finding also supports the notion that after
the ancient gene duplication event that gave rise to the two
-crystallin genes,
A evolved to perform critical functions in the
lens whereas
B, still highly expressed in the lens, evolved into a
more general stress protein. Therefore, although
B may attract
broader interest because of its functions in many extraocular tissues
such as muscle,
A appears to be the more important protein in lens
development and function.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
B knockout mice; Victor Leverenz and students, Navneet Brar, Valery
Heller, Whitney Lakin, Allan Rinke, and Zhilin Yan (Oakland
University), for assistance in the treatment of the mice with
hyperbaric oxygen; Yvonne Duglas-Tabor (National Eye Institute) for
assistance with two-dimensional gel electrophoresis; and Steven Lee
(National Eye Institute) for assistance with mouse genotyping. | Footnotes |
|---|
Supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grant EY02027 (FJG) and Core Center Grant EY05230.
Submitted for publication April 4, 2001; revised July 19, 2001; accepted August 6, 2001.
Commercial relationships policy: N.
The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page
charge payment. This article must therefore be marked
"advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C.
1734
solely to indicate this fact.
Corresponding author: Eric F. Wawrousek, NIH Bldg.6, Room 218, 6 Center Drive MSC 2730, Bethesda, MD 20892-2730. wawrouseke{at}nei.nih.gov
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-Crystallin/small heat shock protein has autokinase activity Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91,3112-3116
-crystallins Curr Eye Res 11,929-933[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
B-Crystallin in cardiac tissue: association with actin and desmin filaments Circ Res 71,288-294
-Crystallin stabilizes actin filaments and prevents cytochalasin-induced depolymerization in a phosphorylation dependent manner Eur J Biochem 242,56-66[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-crystallins modulates intermediate filament assembly EMBO J 13,945-953[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-Crystallins are involved in specific interactions with the murine gamma D/E/F-crystallin-encoding gene Gene 144,171-178[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-Crystallin can function as a molecular chaperone Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89,10449-10453
B-Crystallin is a small heat shock protein Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88,3652-3656
B-crystallin expression Exp Eye Res 54,461-470[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
B-crystallin from human skeletal muscle J Biol Chem 267,7718-7725
A-Crystallin is expressed in non-ocular tissues J Biol Chem 267,23337-23341
A- and
B-Crystallin in the retina: association with the post-Golgi compartment of frog retinal photoreceptors J Biol Chem 269,16853-16861
B Subunit of lens-specific protein
-crystallin is present in other ocular and non-ocular tissues Biochem Biophys Res Commun 158,319-325[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
B-crystallin gene is not restricted to the lens Mol Cell Biol 9,1083-1091
B-crystallin in non-lenticular tissues J Histochem Cytochem 38,31-39[Abstract]
B-crystallin/small heat shock protein gene promoter in transgenic mice Dev Dyn 207,75-88[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
B-crystallin in cardiac and skeletal muscle during mouse development Dev Dyn 208,75-84[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-crystallin/small heat-shock protein/molecular chaperone genes in the lens and other tissues Adv Enzymol Relat Areas Mol Biol 69,155-201[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
B-crystallin chaperone gene causes a desmin-related myopathy Nat Genet 20,92-95[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
A-crystallin gene induces cataract and cytoplasmic inclusion bodies containing the small heat shock protein
B-crystallin Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94,884-889
-crystallin/small hsp family, closely linked to the
B-crystallin gene in a head-to-head manner Genomics 45,386-394[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
B-crystallin Electrophoresis 21,2219-2227[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
A-expressing human lens epithelial cell lines and in
A knockout mouse lenses Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 42,409-416
A- and
B-crystallin in lens epithelial cells J Biol Chem 275,36823-36831
A-crystallin in rat non-lenticular tissues detected with a sensitive immunoassay method Biochim Biophys Acta 1080,173-180[Medline][Order article via Infotrieve]
-crystallin gene CRYAA Hum Mol Genet 7,471-474
A- and
B-crystallin J Biol Chem 273,286-290
A-crystallin and Hsp27 by fluorescence resonance energy transfer and site-directed truncations J Biol Chem 275,1035-1042
A- and
B-crystallins J Biol Chem 274,34067-34071